Do
We Really Need to Stretch?
For several years, the American
College of Sports Medicine
(ACSM) has recommended that
people perform not only cardiovascular
activity and strength training
but also regular flexibility
training. According to ACSM,
flexibility improves joint
range of motion and function
and enhances muscular performance.
ACSM recommends that flexibility
training be performed a minimum
of two to three days per
week.
But not everybody agrees
that flexibility training
is crucial in the fitness
arena. "Stretching is
probably not that important
for the regular fitness athlete," says
Mike Bracko, EdD, CSCS, director
of the Institute for Hockey
Research in Calgary, Alberta. "After
all, how much flexibility
do you need to go for a fitness
run?"
Yet most experts do agree
that flexibility training
- while perhaps not necessary
to excel in step training
or indoor cycling - does
help individuals better perform
daily activities. Douglas
Brooks, MS, a Mammoth Lakes,
California, based exercise
physiologist and personal
trainer, which he defines
as an "aggressive" approach
to improving flexibility
at the joints, can keep individuals
active throughout life. "Flexibility
training will help maintain
range of motion around the
joints," Brooks says.
A good example is the shoulder
joint. If you lose range
of motion in that joint,
you might be unable to reach
a cereal box on the top of
a shelf.
Complicating this issue
is the debate about whether
muscles should be warmed
before they are stretched. "No
matter when you stretch,
whether it's before or
after your workout, you have
to be warmed up," Brooks
says. "Muscles, after
all, are like taffy." Brooks
says that just as cold taffy
will snap and warm taffy
will stretch, muscles are
vulnerable to heat and cold.
Muscles that are cold resist
lengthening. By trying to
stretch cold muscles, you
stand a greater chance of
becoming injured. Yet, after
a 5 to 10 minute aerobic
warm-up, muscles are more
prone to lengthening, so
your chance of gaining flexibility
increases while your risk
of injury decreases.
Not everyone agrees that
warming up is essential for
flexibility. "Warming
up may not have as much impact
on stretching as we once
thought," Bracko says.
He points to employees who
take stretch breaks, without
warming up, to prevent occupational
injuries. However, Bracko
does concur that flexibility
can reduce the risk of injury,
especially the kinds of injury
that occur in the workplace. "Stretching
is extremely important to
prevent and perhaps reverse
occupational muscle imbalances."